ASAM OpenODD Base Standard v1.0.0 Specification, Public Release Candidate (PRC1)

All comments on current page only

/standards/ASAM_Open.../07_04_modules.html

415

Juergen LFeb 25

add a bool class atribute "NOT" (default=false) in order to ma...

414

Juergen LFeb 25

add "NAND", "NOR" operator in order to reach logic completenes...

/standards/ASAM_Open..._taxonomy_yaml.html

413

Juergen LFeb 25

rename the the conversion into "unit_conversion" #container I ...

412

Juergen LFeb 25

is the "cartesian_vector" a propperty/an attribute of Taxonomy...

411

Juergen LFeb 25

reusable_object seems to be a "container", if so then the comm...

347

Juergen LFeb 25

is the road_type record or categorical? is motorway a catecori...

346

Juergen LFeb 25

following code 167 is_danngerous_wind coud be recognized as ca...

345

Juergen LFeb 25

how can reader or parser recognize that light_rain is catecori...

/standards/ASAM_Open...dies_02_ccftap.html

409

Andreas RichterFeb 25

all "bool" should be "boolean"

408

Andreas RichterFeb 25

The expression should contain also the unit (see also line 85 ...

407

Andreas RichterFeb 25

I think a [ is missing.

/standards/ASAM_Open...tudies_03_alks.html

406

Andreas RichterFeb 25

type information is missing, see COD YAML example in correspon...

405

Andreas RichterFeb 25

parents nodes are not required in COD representation

404

Andreas RichterFeb 25

I think in this case LABEL should be TITLE.

403

Andreas RichterFeb 25

I think in this case LABEL should be TITLE.

402

Andreas RichterFeb 25

include other modules should be done with a Boolean value: sub...

401

Andreas RichterFeb 25

multiple INCLUDE_AND section should be summarized in one INCLU...

/standards/ASAM_Open...xml_03_modules.html

400

Andreas RichterFeb 25

. can be removed

399

Andreas RichterFeb 25

element in <> should be set in ´´ like in the other examples

398

Andreas RichterFeb 25

all elements in <> should be set in ´´ like in the other examples

397

Andreas RichterFeb 25

all elements in <> should be set in ´´ like in the other examples

396

Andreas RichterFeb 25

all elements in <> should be set in ´´ like in the other examples

395

Andreas RichterFeb 25

. can be removed

394

Andreas RichterFeb 25

all these elements should be set in ´´

/standards/ASAM_Open...t_modules_yaml.html

393

Andreas RichterFeb 25

We could add an example that "road_type: [low_speed, urban_roa...

392

Andreas RichterFeb 25

The YAML assignment of values (no operator after the colon) is...

391

Andreas RichterFeb 25

change in the second bullet point all " to ´

390

Andreas RichterFeb 25

Replace this with a reference to the tabular format mapping re...

389

Andreas RichterFeb 25

layout issue regarding ``

388

Andreas RichterFeb 25

We can bold this "and" like in the following examples.

/standards/ASAM_Open...abular_modules.html

387

Andreas RichterFeb 25

put AND into ``

386

Andreas RichterFeb 25

put OR into ``

385

Andreas RichterFeb 25

put AND into ``

384

Andreas RichterFeb 25

put OR into ``

383

Andreas RichterFeb 25

All these operators could be layoutet like `AND` and `OR`.

/standards/ASAM_Open...odd_tabular_od.html

382

Andreas RichterFeb 25

rename "prob" it to "fraction"

381

Andreas RichterFeb 25

rename "bool" to "boolean" like in the previous examples

380

Andreas RichterFeb 25

rename it to "RAIN_RATE"

379

Andreas RichterFeb 25

rename it to "RAIN_RATE" and add the unit ";mm/h" to match the...

378

Andreas RichterFeb 25

rename it to "RAIN_RATE" and add the unit ";mm/h" to match the...

377

Andreas RichterFeb 25

rename it to RAIN_RATE and add the unit ";mm/h" to match prev...

376

Andreas RichterFeb 25

rename it to RAIN_RATE and add the unit ";mm/h" to match prev...

375

Andreas RichterFeb 25

Shall be associated with a unit, not a unit type.

323

Andreas RichterFeb 25

";fraction" is missing

322

Andreas RichterFeb 25

";boolean" is missing

320

Andreas RichterFeb 25

";boolean" is missing

319

Andreas RichterFeb 25

delete ";integer"

318

Andreas RichterFeb 25

replace ":" with ";"

316

Andreas RichterFeb 25

";boolean" is missing

315

Andreas RichterFeb 25

";mm/h" is missing

314

Andreas RichterFeb 25

change to ";boolean"

313

Andreas RichterFeb 25

change to capital letters

312

Andreas RichterFeb 25

change to "PEDESTRIAN.COUNT"

311

Andreas RichterFeb 25

";boolean" is missing

309

Andreas RichterFeb 25

";boolean" is missing

307

Andreas RichterFeb 25

These expressions are missing the unit.

/standards/ASAM_Open...07_02_taxonomy.html

374

Andreas RichterFeb 25

Replace the link with a proper reference (also in the followin...

373

Andreas RichterFeb 25

The ' should be replaced by `

/standards/ASAM_Open..._openodd_model.html

372

Gil Amid Feb 25

The example is unclear and potentially wrong. an ODD condition...

371

Gil Amid Feb 25

This is not the ISO 34503 definition of COD, I suggest to sue ...

370

Gil Amid Feb 25

This statement is incompatible with ISO 34503 of OD - I sugges...

369

Gil Amid Feb 25

"situation" implies involvement and behaviours of other actors...

362

Gil Amid Feb 25

See my comment on Code 1 and figure 3 - there is no explanatio...

361

Gil Amid Feb 25

While code 1 is giving an example of mapping between Figure 3 ...

360

Gil Amid Feb 25

The ODD is not specified situations, but rather conditions su...

341

Andreas RichterFeb 25

I suggest to add "road_signs: construction_signs" to illustrat...

340

Andreas RichterFeb 25

change "dsm_" with "module_"

339

Andreas RichterFeb 25

Change _OR to _AND to illustrate the bug. The current version ...

338

Andreas RichterFeb 25

Line #4 should refer to "highway_pilot" module, not to the sce...

335

Andreas RichterFeb 25

change AD to ADS

334

Andreas RichterFeb 25

The list of modules could be indent

333

Andreas RichterFeb 25

": true" is missing after bad_weather

332

Andreas RichterFeb 25

"float" should be replaced by "count"

331

Andreas RichterFeb 25

All attributes should be written with upper cases to match the...

330

Andreas RichterFeb 25

We can remove all * from the comments because they are not cre...

329

Andreas RichterFeb 25

In this example the root node is called "weather".

328

Andreas RichterFeb 25

The name of the class can be put into ``

327

Andreas RichterFeb 25

All IMPORT keywords could be set `IMPORT` like in the previou...

326

Andreas RichterFeb 25

as well as exclude

325

Andreas RichterFeb 25

unnecessary line break can be removed

298

Andreas RichterFeb 25

We need to have clear compliance requirements. It is required ...

251

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

most or all? Where are the others? Suggest either to list them...

185

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Suggest some form of consolidation with the equivalent section...

163

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

This section has a strong overlap with 6.4. I suggest to conso...

104

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Suggest this is a "shall include at least English".

103

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "Since ADAS/AD function..." to "Since ADAS/AD function..."

102

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

But this is not a problem? It is simply the logical design of ...

101

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "The unintended outcome..." to "The unintended outcome..."

100

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

This is not an example of conflicting concepts? I don't see a ...

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Incorrect? The intention is to limit the scope of the ODD to ...

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

What about this is protected? What makes this unprotected?

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

What is an unprotected module?

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Is this not potentially ambiguous? This aligns with OWS, but i...

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

The text currently states: The label supported_pickup_locatio...

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "Add an OR sub-section ..." to "Add an OR sub-section ..."

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "road_marking_color = w..." to "road_marking_color = w..."

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "road_types = motorway..." to "road_types = motorway..."

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

inconsistent free form notation - see use of colons vs use of ...

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "The challenge is that ..." to "The challenge is that ..."

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "In many cases, the inc..." to "In many cases, the inc..."

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "Code 25. Example refer..." to "Code 25. Example refer..."

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

The wording in this section is rather clunky. Propose a rework...

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Why is it unacceptable? In theory it can be done. I think it i...

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Whilst I like the very specific example, a standard should not...

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "If vehicle in a geofen..." to "If vehicle in a geofen..."

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

The second sentence could be clearer. "If fog data were not re...

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "A module can specify a..." to "A module can specify a..."

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "Code 15 shows an upper..." to "Code 15 shows an upper..."

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

This statement is unclear. Does this really mean that a condit...

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

No need for bullet points here.

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "This results in reduci..." to "This results in reduci..."

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

As for the exclude_or, this statement is incorrect? Both state...

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

I think this is incorrect? This condition has nothing to do wi...

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Editorial: Colon without a following listing.

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

The root module also uses the IF-THEN approach, correct? The w...

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "A collection of instan..." to "A collection of instan..."

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "A collection of instan..." to "A collection of instan..."

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "When non-English langu..." to "When the value of the ..."

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

"rows" are a tabular concept that are not present in other for...

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "Each row in the OD rep..." to "Each row in the OD rep..."

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Missing reference to spatial extent section

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Missing reference to temporal extent section

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "Instances of class Tax..." to "Instances of class Tax..."

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "The Operational Domain..." to "The Operational Domain..."

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "A COD related Value in..." to "A COD-related Value in..."

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "There is no minimum re..." to "There is no minimum re..."

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "An instance of COD_OD ..." to "If an instance of COD_..."

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "The COD and the OD are..." to "The COD and the OD are..."

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

"A single measurement is a unique case of a set of measurement...

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "The modules, specified..." to "The modules, specified..."

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "The modules, specified..." to "The modules, specified..."

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "The Operational Domain..." to "The Operational Domain..."

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

I believe this is incorrect. This represents multiple CODs doe...

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

If we use examples in the core spec. they should either be in ...

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

This is technology-specific, not to mention it is a technology...

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Formally speaking there is no need to repeat the abbreviations...

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

typo in graphic: "percipitation_rate"

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

no it isn't? At least not in what is depicted.

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Commenting it here so I don't forget; This is relevant for an ...

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "A Record is a subclass..." to "A Record is a subclass..."

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

shall be unique within the set of transmitted taxonomy files

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

This references a technology-specific topic, which is not mean...

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "When exporting taxonom..." to "When exporting only a ..."

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

these are user stories not use cases?

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

It is my understanding that OpenODD is not seamlessly intercha...

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

not requirements. Design goals?

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Will comment this here, but it also applies to the annex and t...

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

The last sentence may need revision as the assumption at the m...

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "A core principle of th..." to "A core principle of th..."

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "An ASAM OpenODD specif..." to "An ODD specified accor..."

/standards/ASAM_Open...0_introduction.html

368

Gil Amid Feb 25

A "shall" is an obligatory normative statement, I do not think...

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "Normative, except for ..." to "Normative, except for ..."

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Use a list for list-based content.

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

This overview has lost detail to the concept paper. I quite li...

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Lacks clarity (and has a typo). Suggest something like: "The ...

/standards/ASAM_Open...penodd_modules.html

367

Gil Amid Feb 25

Inference ( I assume it is of ODD from modules ) is mentioned ...

366

Gil Amid Feb 25

If this code piece contains an ODD defintion, then one of the ...

365

Gil Amid Feb 25

The statement is not clear. As ISO 34503 definition model are ...

364

Gil Amid Feb 25

The text in this specification section is missing reference an...

363

Gil Amid Feb 25

As this is a free form notation, what does it mean to "define ...

359

Andreas RichterFeb 25

align indent within this example (lines 4 to 7 similar to e.g....

358

Andreas RichterFeb 25

I suggest to start all comments in the same column for better ...

357

Andreas RichterFeb 25

change ":" in line 8 to " is" to match the free form notation ...

356

Andreas RichterFeb 25

change ":" to " is" to match the free form notation of the oth...

355

Andreas RichterFeb 25

indent issue in line 12

354

Andreas RichterFeb 25

Should be class `Modules`.

246

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "The above is represent..." to "The above is represent..."

245

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

How does an imported taxonomy override or extend an existing t...

243

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

set of CODs

242

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

compatible set of CODs?

241

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

This should be expressed in free-form notation or in all formats.

240

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

This should be expressed in free-form notation or in all formats.

239

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

This only works if it is explicit that categorical literals ar...

238

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Consistency with free-form notation, the majority use comma se...

237

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "Each location, for exa..." to "Each location, for exa..."

236

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Based on my previous comment (235) this would then be: .Code ...

235

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

I have a host of concerns with this section. I would like to t...

234

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Does it then make sense to combine all of this into one in the...

233

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Consistency with free-form notation would require a comma sepa...

232

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

The value of this is somehow limited. I think explaining the e...

231

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

This class detail is of little value here. Suggest to move it ...

230

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Missing some form of introduction. Propose to add something li...

229

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Note block

228

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Propose to clarify this further: Expressions follow a struct...

227

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "The ASAM OpenODD model..." to "The ASAM OpenODD model..."

226

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Link to dot notation explanation.

225

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "The CategoricalList co..." to "The CategoricalList co..."

224

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Mixup between lowerbound and upperbound expression

223

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Ouch at the wording ;) Proposal: The LowerBound class define...

222

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

See here and below for formatting issues of code.

221

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

formatting

220

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "Code 86 shows the expr..." to "Code 86 shows the stru..."

219

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Does this mean OpenODD also provides "Interns".

218

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "The expressions within..." to "The expressions within..."

217

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Incorrect probability, should be less than 70%

216

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

incorrect probability? should be "less than 80%"

215

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Link?

214

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "Files can import taxon..." to "Files can import taxon..."

213

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

inconsistent free form notation, also inconsistent with the ex...

212

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Example inconsistency. Description of comments in Yaml. Either...

211

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

What is the value of this section to a user? It has little to ...

209

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Inconsistent use of list notations. "One of" vs comma separate...

208

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Inconsistent free form notation for the definition of categori...

207

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Mixed Use of "is" and ":" for Dot Notation

206

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "MODULES specification ..." to "MODULES specification ..."

205

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

ASAM OpenODD exclusively supports **ESRI Shapefiles** for defi...

204

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

We jump straight in without some introduction of geo-fenced ar...

203

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "Code 80 shows how a sp..." to "Code 80 shows how a sp..."

202

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "Each Module comprises ..." to "Each Module comprises ..."

201

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

.Code 79. Example Module Import and Reference (free-form notat...

200

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

This whole section is confusing. Proposed rework in adoc sourc...

199

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

This section presents some export examples." However, the exa...

198

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "IMPORT the files # A..." to "IMPORT the files # A..."

197

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

As discussed, we should either use free-form notation or consi...

196

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

The title says these are examples of complex conditions. The t...

195

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Free form notation is not consistent with other examples.

194

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Please do not have another location of requirements. Have one ...

193

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Redundant with the introductory sentence.

192

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Search index does not include OpenODD.

191

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Formatting

190

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Section links to itself...

189

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

link incorrect. I would also suggest that we only have ONE com...

188

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Missing clarity on label scoping. Can a label be reused acros...

187

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "Module instances addre..." to "Module instances addre..."

186

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

This is the wrong way around? A header evaluates to true if at...

184

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

This is not fun to read. Suggest a truth table as well. Fun ex...

183

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

This is not correct. If one of the EXCLUDE_AND conditions is...

182

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "Intuitively, both cond..." to "Intuitively, both cond..."

181

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

May be beneficial to also mention what happens when the values...

178

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

It may be beneficial to use truth tables for the examples in 6...

177

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

"it" is presumably the module. This should be made explicit.

175

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

This is only partially correct? A COD or OD instance is only o...

174

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

This is also wrong, see my suggested change in 173. I may be m...

173

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "Code 68 evaluates to t..." to "Code 68 excludes any C..."

172

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Incorrect... From the specification: An EXCLUDE_OR section e...

171

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

This is also logically inverted? "Code 67 evaluates to true u...

170

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

This is logically inverted. "Code 66 evaluates to true if eit...

169

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

This is incorrect; "the exclude section" is not present. The p...

168

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

EXCLUDE_AND is not inherently a negation operation; rather, it...

167

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Does this mean EXCLUDE_* must be explicitly false, or is it si...

166

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

ok I won't comment them all; Please replace "rows" with instan...

165

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "Code 67 evaluates to t..." to "Code 67 evaluates to t..."

164

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "Code 66 evaluates to t..." to "Code 66 evaluates to t..."

162

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

This and the next section are best positioned as part of the c...

161

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "The boolean propositio..." to "The boolean propositio..."

160

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "The ASAM OpenODD model..." to "The ASAM OpenODD model..."

158

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

This is a reoccurring theme across section 6. For readability ...

/standards/ASAM_Open..._03_openodd_od.html

353

Andreas RichterFeb 25

According to Table 45 and 47 this should be "rainfall_type" an...

349

Andreas RichterFeb 25

Due to tooling issues we can't call this class here "COD/OD"? ...

308

Andreas RichterFeb 25

change "bool" to "boolean"

157

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "In certain use cases, ..." to "In certain use cases, ..."

156

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "If contradictions appe..." to "If contradictions appe..."

155

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

This table and those below should make it more clear that this...

154

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Suggest to remove references to json. This is a serialization ...

153

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Another technology-specific reference, this time in JSON. Plea...

152

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "For the example Code 6..." to "The example Code 61 sh..."

151

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Format-specific.

150

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Format-specific

149

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Avoid references to technologies here.

148

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "TAXONOMY: weather ..." to "TAXONOMY: weather ..."

147

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "WIN_SPEED; m/s" to "WIND_SPEED; m/s"

146

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

It can also be represented as a OSC DSL or a YAML file ;) I su...

145

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

This is not made explicit for TEMPORAL_EXTENT, I suggest: Tim...

144

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

How are missing or incomplete time intervals handled?

143

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Does "required" mean mandatory for every instance, or can defa...

142

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "The basic specificatio..." to "The basic specificatio..."

/standards/ASAM_Open...enodd_taxonomy.html

348

Andreas RichterFeb 25

layout issues regarding not proper use of ``

294

Joel GreenyerFeb 25

You write "For example, the length conversions can be specifie...

293

Joel GreenyerFeb 25

Percentile: Do you mean **percentage**? A percentile represe...

292

Joel GreenyerFeb 25

The list does not seem to be complete. What about density?

291

Joel GreenyerFeb 25

Mass is missing. weight is mass * gravitational acceleration (g)

290

Joel GreenyerFeb 25

Duration and time are both listed, but they overlap in meaning...

289

Joel GreenyerFeb 25

acceleration = velocity / time^2 is WRONG it is acceleration ...

288

Joel GreenyerFeb 25

Reliability typically refers to the probability of no failure ...

287

Joel GreenyerFeb 25

For the unit types, it is not clear which base units they depe...

286

Joel GreenyerFeb 25

This text is wrong: "A TaxonomyConcept instance shall referen...

274

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "The instruction compri..." to "The instruction compri..."

270

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Listing leads to an example block. Please remove the colon.

210

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

This has the potential to be ambiguous. Code 81 in 6.4.5 uses...

141

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

This was reviewed by others in the team, I think a discussion ...

140

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

This can cause alot of issues down the road, I have put a prop...

139

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

It is ambiguous what "aggregation type" means in this context:...

138

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

What happens if the input data contains missing or invalid val...

137

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Does the dot notation always reference a hierarchy of concept ...

136

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Either this specification specifies all the aggregations or it...

135

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "For COD and OD associa..." to "For COD and OD associa..."

134

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "The following list sho..." to "The following list sho..."

133

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

This may raise a pandoras box of discussion, but here a sugges...

132

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "Measures are regarded ..." to "Measures are regarded ..."

131

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Text is missing a key clarification on scope: It does not spe...

130

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

What about inheritance? Do instances of a record (e.g., motor...

129

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

what happens if a cyclic dependency is introduced (e.g., does ...

128

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

formatting

127

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

What happens if thresholds are overlapping or inconsistent? Is...

126

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

How are overlapping or invalid ranges handled (e.g., if modera...

125

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

The description "equivalent to an enumerated type" is useful b...

124

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

The text says "verified against an expression referring to thi...

123

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

122

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "The TaxonomyConcept is..." to "The TaxonomyConcept is..."

121

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Formatting indicates a code element, I think that is incorrect.

120

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

fix formatting of code element

117

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Check use of bullets.

116

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

i.e.

115

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

see editorial guide for abbreviations like e.g./ii.e.

114

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "Categorical: are simil..." to "Categorical: is simila..."

113

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "Container: an aggregat..." to "Container: an aggregat..."

112

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "A TaxonomyConcept is e..." to "A TaxonomyConcept is e..."

111

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Are there concepts that are not depicted here but that are par...

110

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Please check editorial guide for guidance on formatting of lis...

109

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "Categorical or" to "Categorical"

108

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "Type , which always ei..." to "Type , which is always..."

107

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "Container (sometimes c..." to "Container (analagous t..."

106

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "Concepts: Concepts are..." to "Concepts: Concepts are..."

105

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "Concepts: Concepts are..." to "Concepts: Concepts are..."

/standards/ASAM_Open...bular_taxonomy.html

344

Juergen LFeb 25

wind_speed shall be as above a float and not a record (otherwi...

343

Juergen LFeb 25

wind_speed shall be as above a float and not a record (otherwi...

342

Juergen LFeb 25

The type column could be also a "container" as specified in UM...

305

Andreas RichterFeb 25

Layout issue.

304

Andreas RichterFeb 25

Remove the VWCV abbreviations here as well.

303

Andreas RichterFeb 25

Remove the VWCV abbreviations here as well.

302

Andreas RichterFeb 25

The expressions are missing a unit because the taxonomy concep...

301

Andreas RichterFeb 25

These abbreviations ("VWCV") are not necessary here (and in th...

259

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

What happens when multiple taxonomy files define the same conc...

258

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

What is meant by denormalized in this context? Are relationshi...

257

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "The purpose of the Sec..." to "This section provides ..."

Aniket SalviFeb 25

Incorrect reference,refers to Table 122

/standards/ASAM_Open...503_01_tabular.html

337

Andreas RichterFeb 25

Reference is broken.

/standards/ASAM_Open...so34503_04_xml.html

336

Andreas RichterFeb 25

We do have received all official Chinese as well as Japanese t...

/standards/ASAM_Open...cod_od_mapping.html

324

Andreas RichterFeb 25

all "bool" should be changed to "boolean"

306

Andreas RichterFeb 25

Replace all square brackets with semicolon as it is done in se...

/standards/ASAM_Open..._01_hands_free.html

297

EddieFeb 25

This is not compliant YAML: * It uses elements which are not i...

/standards/ASAM_Open...d_schema_intro.html

256

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

This document has no deliverables. It is a part of the deliver...

255

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Listing, followed by sections. Please move the format examples...

254

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

Change "A tabular representati..." to "A tabular representati..."

253

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

These are a duplicate of the section in 6.2

252

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

The mapping reference is not a specification in itself; it des...

/standards/ASAM_Open...odel_reference.html

244

Benjamin EngelFeb 25

The location of this section is very much redundant. ASAM offi...

/standards/ASAM_Open...nd_definitions.html

Benjamin EngelFeb 25